GBU ..the new numbers are out

[Nickatilynx]

The figures have just been posted.

http://www.goodbadugly.info/top20.htm

And at No1 is steamray with 1 in 36!!!!

No2 is APS with a 1 in 204

Oh come on!!!!

I'm a fucking partner in the GBU and frankly I'm calling Bullshit!!!!!!!!

1.) How many hits are sent , not counted.
2.) How many signups? (For 1 in 36 ...I suspect errr ONE)

Seriously come on boys...

I am a partner in this and I am sure the integrity of the GBU needs to be maintained.

Hence why I'm not skulking about in private doing this.


I'd like some answers here...seriously those figures are a joke...

[Anthony]

I agree. Stats should show how many total hits were sent.

I did 1:12 with a program once, best 12 clicks I've ever sent anywhere.

Who are these programs?

What sites were sent too?

[Nickatilynx]

Exactly , Ant!!!!

I mean this is when I dispair.

Its the fucking Mickey Mouse Club

I send certain people here traffic (cough) that is basically filtered to the Ninth degree and I can't get to those numbers over 10 joins or higher.

Serge passed on the GBU and I think its integrity is paramount.

These figures are to any webmaster with experience a joke.

And that is not decrying the programs listed.

I just do not believe we are showing a fair comparison

[Anthony]

Looking at that page, I can do the same thing choosing randomly from any programs out there.

What imho should be reported:

1. How much traffic was sent
2. What type of traffic was sent
3. Percentage of traffic from source
4. What sites were sent too or what niche
5. How many first pages, how many join pages
6. How much money was made off of said joins.
7. ROI of click

Just putting up ratios is bullshit. It makes no sense, and frankly I wouldn't believe it for one second. Anyone can put up numbers. I have no idea who those 2 top programs are, but am expected to believe they convert traffic that well?

Bullshit.

[Anthony]

Just an FYI...

This was listed:

Gigacash
1:2167/1:1378 Gigaconverts

I don't know what type of experience the person has with traffic and signups, but if they think 1:2167 means Giga cash converts, then that person needs to be replaced with someone who knows what the fuck they are talking about.

GBU of old has always been the measuring stick. This new GBU is a joke.

[JoesHO]

How are the numbers compiled in total would be my question. ( not asking for the sources) just the methodology's

[BillPMB]

Steamray? Give me a break.

uniques free signups pps earned chargebacks/credits
Totals: 9230 52 0 $0.00 $0.00

And that was targetted cam traffic. I pointed it back to click cash and then
kicked myself in the nuts for being so stupid in the first place.

[DrGuile]

Lol, can I steal the punchline of this thread that's coming in a few dozens message and a couple days?

LegendaryLars/Streamray become's an Oprano sponsor after confirming that those ratios a are real...


Wow, what an unexpected turn of event...


YAWN!

[Anthony]

In light of Bill's post of stats, I'd like to see the stats on the top 3 made public.

[Nickatilynx]

Originally posted by Anthony@Apr 5 2005, 08:54 AM
Looking at that page, I can do the same thing choosing randomly from any programs out there.

What imho should be reported:

1. How much traffic was sent
2. What type of traffic was sent
3. Percentage of traffic from source
4. What sites were sent too or what niche
5. How many first pages, how many join pages
6. How much money was made off of said joins.
7. ROI of click

Just putting up ratios is bullshit. It makes no sense, and frankly I wouldn't believe it for one second. Anyone can put up numbers. I have no idea who those 2 top programs are, but am expected to believe they convert traffic that well?

Bullshit.

Ex - fucking - actly!!!!

Lets do it properly or lets not do it.

I mean every webmaster that knows this game spewed coffee over his monitor when he read those figures.

Seriously no excuse for it.

If thats what the RAW data said , it should have been looked into.

I mean its a fundamental, obvious and basic error.

[DrGuile]

Originally posted by Anthony@Apr 5 2005, 11:54 AM
Looking at that page, I can do the same thing choosing randomly from any programs out there.

What imho should be reported:

1. How much traffic was sent
2. What type of traffic was sent
3. Percentage of traffic from source
4. What sites were sent too or what niche
5. How many first pages, how many join pages
6. How much money was made off of said joins.
7. ROI of click

Just putting up ratios is bullshit. It makes no sense, and frankly I wouldn't believe it for one second. Anyone can put up numbers. I have no idea who those 2 top programs are, but am expected to believe they convert traffic that well?

Bullshit.

I do agree that this information is vital to any stats. TheStatistician was doing it right if you ask me (or as close as humanly possible)

But for those crying for GBU of old, it didnt have any of that info.

[TheEnforcer]

Just an FYI.. Lars is not a sponsor here, and had the top spot last month as well if memory serves me correctly, though it's not for lack of trying on my part. And I'm still gonna keep trying to get him!!

[Anthony]

Originally posted by DrGuile+Apr 5 2005, 09:03 AM-->