I'm with Peaches - I've never been with anyone who wasn't circumsized so in my limited experience I have to say "cut" just for not knowing any better. lol
We debated this SO long when my son was born and in the end decided to have it done so he would "look like daddy" - I know, I know. Well, the other reason was that my father-in-law had just had to HAVE it done a few months prior - in his 50's - and we didn't want our son to have to go through the same thing.
Serge - sorry you had to go through it so late, but sounds like (as always!) you made the best of it. lol