PDA

View Full Version : Piracy/DMCA Hypothetical...


Toby
10-20-2009, 10:31 AM
Situation:
- A surfer forum, posting links to files with 'stolen' content.
- Sample images from said content collection posted to free hosting site such as imagevenue.
- thumb images of those samples posted to the surfer forum, hotlinked from the free image host along with link to a file sharing host, such as rapidshare, for the full collection of images.

Question: Obviously the file sharing host and free image host must comply with a DMCA to remove those files. Would a DMCA also apply to the forum host? The images are published on a page on the forum, even though they're not hosted on the same server.

sarettah
10-20-2009, 01:24 PM
Situation:
- A surfer forum, posting links to files with 'stolen' content.
- Sample images from said content collection posted to free hosting site such as imagevenue.
- thumb images of those samples posted to the surfer forum, hotlinked from the free image host along with link to a file sharing host, such as rapidshare, for the full collection of images.

Question: Obviously the file sharing host and free image host must comply with a DMCA to remove those files. Would a DMCA also apply to the forum host? The images are published on a page on the forum, even though they're not hosted on the same server.

I have been told by my super secret source that the answer is YES.

:okthumb:

RawAlex
10-20-2009, 01:26 PM
My magic 8 ball says "all signs point to yes"

pornlaw
10-20-2009, 08:31 PM
Yes....

Toby
10-20-2009, 08:50 PM
Thanks :)

Hell Puppy
10-21-2009, 08:38 PM
Situation:
- A surfer forum, posting links to files with 'stolen' content.
- Sample images from said content collection posted to free hosting site such as imagevenue.
- thumb images of those samples posted to the surfer forum, hotlinked from the free image host along with link to a file sharing host, such as rapidshare, for the full collection of images.

Question: Obviously the file sharing host and free image host must comply with a DMCA to remove those files. Would a DMCA also apply to the forum host? The images are published on a page on the forum, even though they're not hosted on the same server.

I have used DMCA to have stuff removed from Yahoo Groups in almost that exact scenario.